Chicken Broth
10.0Lighter flavor but works in most recipes
Frying ranges 350-400°F, far above any broth's 212°F boiling point, so beef broth here acts as a pre-sear braising liquid or a post-sear deglaze — never a frying medium. Substitutes must tolerate a hot pan hit without scorching their solids; watery swaps flash to steam and cool the crust, killing the Maillard reaction. This page ranks substitutes by solids-to-water ratio and how quickly they evaporate without burning sugars or milk solids onto the pan.
Lighter flavor but works in most recipes
Use 1:1 as a post-sear deglaze, not a frying medium — water boils at 212°F, well below the 350°F pan. Pour 1/4 cup into the hot skillet 30 seconds after meat comes out; it flashes to steam and lifts fond faster than beef broth's thicker gelatin load.
Mix with 1 cup water for quick savory broth
Mix 1 tbsp soy with 1 cup water for a post-fry glaze; add only after oil is drained. Straight soy in a 375°F pan scorches its sugars in 8 seconds and turns acrid. Diluted, it caramelizes cleanly over 90 seconds for a sticky sear finish.